Creating share

Welcome to McCaskey Orthodontics

Dr. Theodore J. McCaskey, Dr. Lyndsey B. McCaskey, and our team have been providing comfortable, conservative, family-oriented orthodontics in Butler, Grove City, and Saxonburg, PA since 1998! Our practice focuses on you, our patient, and helping you achieve better oral health and a beautiful, confident smile. Drs. Theodore and Lyndsey McCaskey work with each patient individually, starting with a complimentary consultation, and oversee the entire treatment from start to finish. Our goal is to provide a family-oriented environment and to make the orthodontic experience fun, enjoyable, and comfortable. 

Our practice provides several effective orthodontic treatment options, including Invisalign®, 3M Clarity™, ceramic braces, and two-phase orthodontic treatment. Drs. Theodore and Lyndsey McCaskey evaluate each case and provide an individual treatment plan, which can be comprehensive and treated in one phase, or, if indicated, treated with two-phase orthodontic treatment.

We pride ourselves on our level of commitment to our patients, and our ability to give people of all ages the smiles they have always wanted. Please schedule your complimentary new-patient consultation at our Butler, Grove City, or Saxonburg office. We look forward to working with you!

Meet Dr. Ted

Theodore J. McCaskey
DDS, Angle Society, AAO
Dr. Theodore McCaskey is an experienced, gentle orthodontist who provides patient-focused, conservative treatment that improves his patients’ lives. In concentrating on each patient’s unique clinical and personal needs, Dr. McCaskey creates one-of-a-kind smiles.

Meet Dr. Lyndsey

Lyndsey B. McCaskey
Dr. Lyndsey McCaskey takes great pleasure in getting to know her patients on a personal level. She works hard to give patients the attention they deserve in a comfortable, considerate, and welcoming environment.

We treat the whole family


The clear solution to orthodontic treatment, Invisalign aligners use removable trays to straighten teeth without the hassle of metal brackets and wires.

Early Orthodontic Care

Early treatment makes room for permanent teeth to come in properly and lessens the need of extractions in the future.

Clear Braces

Clear braces offer a less noticeable alternative to traditional metal braces but provide patients with equally effective treatment and results.

Traditional Braces

The gold standard of orthodontic treatment, traditional metal braces are effective, efficient, and more comfortable than ever before!

View Our Patient

View More

What Our Patients Are Saying

“The McCaskey Orthodontics office is truly top notch. The staff is so caring and extremely knowledgeable. Both Dr. McCaskey and Dr. Goddard are passionate about making sure their patients are comfortable and getting the best results. I love how involved this office is in the communities it serves as well.” — Maggie B. “Caring and personalized treatment. Dr McCaskey truly cares about what is best for his patients. Your child will be able to participate in many contests that have fun rewards. Kids love this office!” — Linda L. “Most of my family went to Dr. McCaskey for orthodontic treatment and he did an outstanding job! All of the staff are super friendly and I would recommend them to anyone.” — Kevin W. “McCaskey Orthodontics provides excellent care. The staff are friendly and kind. They truly care about their patients. McCaskey also is constantly giving back by sponsoring fun events for their patients, Teacher of the Year contests, and other contests. Thanks to McCaskey Orthodontics for giving my daughter a beautiful smile.” — T.M. “Dr. McCaskey treats each patient as an individual. This is apparent when you have your free consultation.The office staff is caring, kind, and considerate. My daughters (one as a teen, and the other as an adult) loved this office. If you are thinking about braces, be sure to give them a call.” — Linda M. “We had our initial consultation for our daughter this morning. Dr. McCaskey and his staff were very friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable!” — Gabrielle P.
Schedule your Complimentary Consultation